Dear vocalisters,
Thank you all for your great responses to my Opinions solicited query. I will share some of the responses and ideas here in one e-mail in case someone else with a similar question is reading this and could benefit from your help.
Thank you, Dr. Diane, for helping me to remember that it does not matter so much what voice type I am as long as I enjoy singing. Sometimes we get so caught up in so many petty details that it robs singing of its joy.
Mr. Blyth (since you responded to me very formally as Ms. Ardrey ;) you wrote: <<<Ms. Ardrey, I think I'm much more self-absorbed than you, but here is what I want to know anyway!...
When you sing something you like from the radio or such, where does your voice lie?>>>
Answer: in the high part of middle!
<<< Can you find very odd squeaks way above that elusive high C?>
Answer: Nope!
>>> What sort of feedback have you had from teachers and other singers when you have attempted really low repertoire?>>>
Answer: I haven't really attempted *really* low repertoire in public, but when I sing alto in church choir, people seem surprised that I can do it (*pleasantly* surprised, I hope.)
<<<What is your speaking voice like? Do you feel you aupport appropriately?>>>
I do have a low speaking voice, although I think that talking may be a part of my problem; since I teach four-year old kindergarten I talk, sing, and read aloud all day long. I'm not sure I speak correctly. I have good support when I sing, but I'm not sure it's correct when I speak.
<<<What is your vibrato like in different parts of your range?>>>
Answer: I like my vibrato. It is neither too fast or slow.
<<< I think (perhaps only I) that most voices have a wide range of capabilities, for instance, I can sound like a true bass, if I don't go too low and expose me for the baritone I am. I can also sound like a tenor, provided you don't want any of those horrible high 'c's out of me. And I can sound like a variety of baritones, any choose to, depending on the repertoire I am called upon to do, or that I choose to do. presumably there is one thing that I can do the best, though it wouldn't surprise me if the next best thing is still pretty close. All that seems to be clear from your post is that high notes have givenyou grief, either because of technique ideas, or because your voice doesn't go there.>>>
This could apply to me as well, if you substituted alto for bass, and soprano for tenor. I agree with you wholeheartedly. My main concern was whether the higher literature I was studying was harmful to my voice.
Thank you, John, for your questions and advice!
From Christine:
<<<Hey, the letter "I" is very important to us singers. After, all just take it out of "recital" and what do you get???>>
Thanks for making me feel better about sending my self-centered post!
Thank you all, Cathy Ardrey
|