Hello Reg
On 20-Feb-01, Reg Boyle wrote: > Some am I correct in assuming that you are saying Lloyd, > that EACH of the three elements can be altered independent > of the state of either of the other two? Boolean logic says > that is EIGHT possible conditions disregarding intermediate > states. Peace at last! > That means there are only eight was > of singing. Oh joy oh bliss!!! Reg.
COMMENT: In my experience the concept of raising the palate such that the larynx is simultaneously lowered is a natural and easily taught posture that has a very desirable effect on the tone quality of the singer. Some claim that the larynx can be lowered or raised without any contrary movement of the palate. I have never found anyone who could do that but that does not mean it could not be done. I just cannot think of any reason why one would want to void a natural response of these muscle systems. Perhaps it is necessary to achieve a particular kind of tonal quality that is required for some styles of singing.
Miller gives a variety of sources on how the velopharyngeal port can be, or is, closed. It is his opinion that some good tones which do not appear to have a nasal quality may, in fact, allow some partial opening of the velopharyngeal port.
I can send you a copy of his discussion of this matter from his book, "The Structure of Singing".
About Boolean probability? Who knows from Boolean probability?
Regards -- Lloyd W. Hanson, DMA Professor of Voice, Vocal Pedagogy School of Performing Arts Northern Arizona University Flagstaff, AZ 86011# #
|