Dear Reg and Vocalisters:
I can only share with you what I have found to be an effective way of teaching voice. It is based on study of the vocal mechanism without an attempt to support or prove any particular point of view but rather to discover what happens when we sing well. The study is ongoing and very incomplete.
One must begin with a correct and efficient phonation and understand the effects of incorrect phonation on the vocal tone. Pressed or breathy vocal qualities, for example, are the results of phonation adjustments and cannot be corrected by changes in the resonance characteristics of the vocal tract.
As phonational concerns are addressed the studen can also began the process of understanding vocal resonance. Singers usually are able to pronounce all of the spoken vowels in their native language without difficulty. If singers are made aware of the tongue and mouth/lip positions used to form these vowels, they are well on their way toward producing a quality singing tone provided there is no other attempt to "fix" these pronunciations.
If the tone is too bright or thin or if the tone is too dark or thick, slight adjustments of the tongue, mouth/lips, and pharyngeal space can be added or subtracted within the speech vowel function to achieve the desired corrections. Such tonal adjustments are more natural than contrived if they can be achieved without attempting to isolate one portion of the vocal tract to the exclusion of the others.
We all make such natural adjustments when we use the voice in a manner that is different from normal speech. We all tend to open the vocal tract when we yell to someone and the louder we yell the more adjustment we make. But we make these adjustments based on our speech, not on some image of raising the palate, lowering the larynx, opening the pharynx, or singing through the top of the head, floating the tone, keeping on the breath, etc. We simply choose to be heard regardless of the quality of the sound.
We might try yelling into an echoing canyon. There are lots of those in Arizona. And we might try adjusting our echoed sound to improve or degrade its quality. All of these changes are made with no concern for the mechanistic alterations that singers are so carefully taught.
Learning to understand how vowels are produced, that is, what vocal tract formations we use to produce the differences in vowels, gives the singer a more accurate understanding of how his instrument functions. It points the singer toward his habitual and more easily produced tonal qualities without requiring his altering what he has not yet understood.
Only after he has gained a knowledge of his own vowel production will be ready to make any adjustments in that production. Such adjustments will, in effect, be slight changes to his already habitual use of the vocal tract. And such changes can be more easily made because the singer now knows the vocal tract formations necessary for each vowel and, therefore, how slight changes in these formations will affect the tone.
Sometimes singers come to teachers with such distorted concepts of how to produce tone that the teacher must, in effect, teach the singer how to speak. But even in these extreme cases the bad singing habits are not often presented in the students speech habits. It then becomes logical to point the student towards his speech vowel production and build a singing vowel production from that foundation.
Singing is different from speech. But the resonance function of the vocal tract is more alike between singing and speech than it is different. That resonance function similarity is most present in vowel production. It has been my experience that a singer makes the fastest and smoothest improvement when he/she is becomes more aware of the function of the elements of the vocal tract in producing each spoken vowel, and the formation of the vocal tract for the singing form of a vowel is built on the formation of the vocal tract for the speech form of the vowel.
With such knowledge it is not as necessary to involve the student in isolated adjustments of the vocal tract nor is it required that one build a library of images that, at best, can be carried from one individual to another only with great difficulty.
Regards -- Lloyd W. Hanson, DMA Professor of Voice, Vocal Pedagogy School of Performing Arts Northern Arizona University Flagstaff, AZ 86011
|