Vocalist.org archive


From:  Jeffrey Joel <JSJoel@c...>
Date:  Sun Apr 16, 2000  2:07 am
Subject:  Re: [vocalist-temporary] never again a singing teacher, was: fa


>Sorry, I fail to see how the fact that one (apparently bad) voice teacher
>mis-classified you makes it impossible for men to teach women or vice versa.

It doesn't necessarily do so. However, what do most voice teachers tend to
teach as the first thing to someone who already knows a fair amount about
music?
From reading this list it seems to be "support". But I had already been a
professional wind player for 7 years. So rather than things like
relaxation and
the proper approach to moving through the zona di passaggio, she taught me
bass literature, which I would sing with a great deal of weight, but it
was always
uncomfortable to me. When I mentioned it to her, she dismissed it as my
imagination.
If I wanted to study voice at all, she was the only teacher available to
me at
that time and place. Eventually I stopped singing for more than 25 years.


Bless Your Heart(s),

Jeffrey Joel
JSJoel@c...

Circulation
Crone Chronicles: A Journal of Conscious Aging


emusic.com