I have/had/am working through, the same problem.
In order for my brain to be happy I need to understand what my body/larynx/soft palate are doing. Having a teacher who can explain things in physiological terms as well pictorial and artistic ones has been essential for me. I think that having this kind of information will also help long term, since I will be more able to 'fix' myself through understanding the problems which the voice can experience and the physiology behind them.
However, the flip side is that now the main blocks are in place (6 years, but I probably said the same after 2,3,4,5 years !) I really have to work out ways to 'let go' and let the voice/body do what it's been trained to do. This lets the voice engage at a whole new level. At the moment I can generate a window of about one second, by taking on the character of 'Mr Stupid Person', just before singing an excersize. If I hit the window the voice does completely different things (an exaggeration) from when I sing the excersize thinking about my technique. I'm simply enjoying the sensations and letting the body 'do it's stuff'.
On the other flip side, I've had Richard Miller on my shelf (I should be so lucky!) unread for about three years because I'm afraid it might be too technical and get my brain in knots.
As to solutions to being over intellectual with your singing, it depends on who you are and what you need. Perhaps you don't have enough technical knowledge from your teacher to satisfy your mind. In which case maybe read Richard Miller and that'll put your mind at ease sufficiently to allow your artistic nature to take over. Perhaps you simply treat singing too intellectually because that's how your head works. In which case if you get the chance to perform a role at whatever level you're at then TAKE IT ! If you are an intellectual type chap then getting inside the skin of another character will take your mind off all the mechanics and allow the voice to really work . Or maybe try Tai-Chi / Alexander Technique ...... Go to more art galleries, sit by a river......
I don't beleive that a person can learn to sing well through understanding the physiology but I think that they may well be able to help themselves more easily through the times when the voice isn't working so well.
Kevin.
|