> In the recording I have, these arias are sung by baritone singing falsetto - > it sounds much better. Falsetto gives them a little unusual color and > changes the meaning a bit: from just a very high aria, to a something witch > goes along with the whole CB sound, maybe even magic (for a lack of a better > word), enchanted sound. > > I haven't heard CT singing it, but I bet, he can bring some color to it too! > It would be nice to know what Orff actually wanted there....
Dear Maria,
I think you're right. The orchestration for the swan aria is just too thin to suggest a tenor screeching out his highest notes. Plus, as you mention, there is quite a bit of "falsetto" work for the baritone elsewhere in the oratorio, suggesting the baritone might be able to do the swan aria as well...
-Tako
|
| |