Vocalist.org archive


From:  "Cynthia Donnell" <csdonnell@m...>
Date:  Thu Jul 27, 2000  11:32 pm
Subject:  Re: [vocalist-temporary] is icecream bad for voice?


Mr. Smith:
I beg to differ with this statement:
>all due respect Lloyd, but that's exactly what a Professor>would say. >
I believe that what Lloyd said is what anyone who understands critical
thinking would say.

His point regarding the importance of the remarks of "celebrities" is well
taken. What Mr. Baxter says is opinion or anecdote,not fact, until proven
otherwise.

regards,
Cynthia Donnell, skeptic

-----Original Message-----
From: Roger Smith <roger@c...>
>"Lloyd W. Hanson" wrote:
>> Dear Carlo and Vocalisters.
>> Who is Mark Baxter and what are his qualifications?

>all due respect Lloyd, but that's exactly what a Professor
>would say.
>
>> Can he support
>> his claim about the consumption of calcium in the stomach with
>> medical research. If not, he should be ignored regardless of how
>> exciting he might be in performance. Performer seldom know what they
>> are talking about, The simply perform.
>
>I think you should also back up what you're saying about
>performers in that case with research.
>peace>Rodge>

>> --
>> Lloyd W. Hanson, DMA



emusic.com