Isabelle asked:"what do you tell a student who refuses to use ANY effort to support?"
I call support one of the "magic wand" words because we seem to think it will magically fix anything. And as teachers, we tend to wave that word over our students way too much, IMO;-)
Support is a coordination effect, not one thing, but several things working together, including breath management and body alignment. Especially for a singer who has concerns about forcing things (even if she's actually forcing her voice more in the process) it might help to focus more on language that does not mention "support" or anything that might imply force to this student.
Alexander-based body alignment is extremely helpful as a basis for this work...once the body is aligned (no mention of pulling, pushing, bearing down, etc., just emphasis on proper alignment as useful for living as it is for singing) then, you can start to get the breathing coordinated better with this alignment, and then the onset of tone and resonance coordinated with the rest. When those skills start working together, I'd be surprised if she continues to sing from the throat.
Exercises that encourage alignment and channel energy well are also useful: knee bends and arm raises on the highest note of the phrase for example; and running in place with hands clasped while singing (you won't sound great on this one, but it's still a useful exercise.)
One of the tougher jobs a voice teacher has is to try to think as each student does, instead of how *we* like to think. In this case, I'd be sure to affirm to the student that force has no place in proper singing, but that Singing is a Sport, and one can expect to put forth some physical exertion in the process. It's not just the hot lights that make us sweat when we sing, hahaha, and creating (and harnessing) energy is much of what makes us exciting as performers.
-y
_Dr. Yvonne Dechance Email: ydechance@s..., Homepage: http://www.scaredofthat.com/yworld/ The Diction Domain: Free voice diction resources for singers http://over.to/dictiondomain
_________________________________________________________________
| | |