In a message dated 8/5/2001 5:31:49 AM Eastern Daylight Time, w.ritzerfeld@c... writes: w.ritzerfeld@c... writes:
<< 2. The 1 to 6 ratio between the tube diameters stems from Sundberg. This seems to be the key factor in SF.
3. Low larynx and power. I'm not sure whether it is possible to produce a significant SF with a high larynx. I will look into this but it seems unlikely to me, as I can't imagine a C&W singer using 'twang' cut through an orchestra without amplification.>>
wim,
where there is so much singing that exhibits a low larynx without significant presence of the singer's formant, it does make sense to me that it would be created somewhere else. at its source, i am sure that there is a maximum level it can be produced. it seems sensible to me (and i can only speak through personal and teaching experience) that larynx height has a more immediate affect on timbre than power (and, i think the skill level of most students has as much to do with this as anything else). of course, if the larynx is lowered without interfering with the SF signal, then the ratio is increased and power maximized (does that make sense?).
regarding how much SF can be produced with a high larynx, it has been my experience that it can be quite significant. i just did an experiment here it home on it and the same notes sung with a high larynx produced no noticeable change in the region of the SF (according to gram50, as i read it) from those sung with a low larynx. there are significant changes everywhere else. the most obvious change is in sound quality, obvious to that dated instrument, the human ear. (i could post the file if someone could tell me how.)
high SF production accompanied by a high larynx, by most standards, is considered an ugly sound. however, there are some cultures where it is considered beautiful. senegal would be such a place with baaba maal the most well known example (although youssou n'dour is gaining in popularity, he does not exhibit this type of singing to the degree that other sengalize singers do). (incidently, baaba maal is one of my very favorite singers.)
i would guess a country singer singing with a high larynx would be attempting soften the sound by reducing the SF at the source and therefore, would not be attempting to produce as much as possible.
my question remains then, does maximizing resonance, by lowering the larynx, both increase the SF and diffuse it? is that possible?
mike
|