I think the proper response to your comment is:
Your mileage may vary. It's clearly a question of different technical approach. All I know is that what I described has helped me ELIMINATE the "breathy onset" problem that plagued me for years, and the general approach to breathing has helped me ELIMINATE the faulty breath management that also plagued me for years, as well as my tendency to overcompress (due, in part, to tightening in the tongue and jaw when I used to "draw in" breaths rather than "allow breaths to happen"). The evidence is that I'm able to sing freely, easily, much longer phrases on one breath, and I've discovered an extreme facility with coloratura (no small discovery for a dramatic-sized contralto voice), and an ease in my very top register that I never had before I changed my approach to taking breaths and to starting onsets. The third part of the process has been learning to allow the phrase to taper off, releasing at the end, instead of trying to keep the sound spinning through muscular effort (which causes tensions and prevents an easy release into the next phrase).
Sorry if your technical approach is in conflict with this. Perhaps what you do works for you and for other singers. But I know that what I do - what my teacher teaches - works beautifully for all the singers in her studio (at least the 40 or so that I've seen and heard). Indeed, I was extremely encouraged to discover that so many of her students get it right, having come from a teacher who had only a small handful of students that I'd seen/heard of whom I could say the same.
KM +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ + Singers are often so fired up after a + + a performance, they want sex instantly. + + - Jilly Cooper, SCORE! + +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
| |